Comment on Decline of Liberalism [UPSC 2024/10m/150w/1d]

Decline of Liberalism: Liberalism, once a dominant political ideology championing individual rights, democracy, and free markets, has faced a significant decline in recent years. This shift can be attributed to the rise of populism, authoritarianism, and socio-economic disparities that challenge the liberal order. The increasing polarization of societies, coupled with growing skepticism about globalization and its impact, has further eroded confidence in liberal values. This Question explores the reasons behind the decline of liberalism and its implications for contemporary political and social systems.

Outline for the Answer: Decline of Liberalism

  1. Introduction
    • Definition of liberalism: Focus on individual freedom, equal rights, democratic governance, rule of law, and free markets.
    • Reference to John Locke’s emphasis on life, liberty, and property.
    • Historical roots: Emergence from the medieval period, advocating human reason and autonomy.
    • Contemporary dominance alongside signs of decline.
  2. Challenges to Liberalism
    • Rise of Right-Wing Movements
      • Opposition to liberal policies on immigration and multiculturalism.
      • Arguments about threats to national sovereignty and identity.
      • Examples: Growth of right-wing politics in Europe and the USA.
    • Critiques from Postmodernism
      • Postmodernist thinkers (Nietzsche, Derrida) questioning objective truth and universal values.
      • Emphasis on the relativity of truth undermining liberalism’s moral authority.
  3. Resilience of Liberalism
    • Historical adaptability to changing societal dynamics.
    • Potential for liberalism to incorporate contemporary challenges and evolve further.
  4. Conclusion
    • Acknowledgment of liberalism’s decline in certain areas.
    • Optimistic outlook on its ability to adapt and maintain relevance.

Sample Answer

As a political ideology, liberalism prioritizes individual freedom, equal rights, democratic governance, the rule of law, and free markets. John Locke, often regarded as the father of liberalism, famously emphasized the rights to life, liberty, and property. Emerging as a beacon of hope during the dark medieval period, liberalism champions human reason and individual autonomy. While it remains a dominant ideology today, its decline is evident in some areas.

One of the primary challenges to liberalism stems from the rise of right-wing movements, which oppose liberal policies on immigration and multiculturalism, arguing that they threaten national sovereignty and identity. This trend is reflected in the increasing influence of right-wing politics in Europe and the United States in recent years.

Additionally, postmodernist thinkers like Nietzsche and Derrida have questioned the notions of objective truth and universal values, weakening liberalism’s moral authority. Postmodernism’s emphasis on the relativity of truth undermines the universal principles that liberalism upholds.



Despite these challenges, liberalism has demonstrated remarkable resilience over time. By adapting to contemporary changes rather than resisting them, it may continue to thrive in the face of evolving societal dynamics. [190 words]

Evaluation of the Answer

Strengths:

  1. Clarity and Structure:
    • The answer is well-structured with a clear introduction, discussion of challenges, and conclusion.
    • Logical flow from defining liberalism to addressing its challenges and potential for resilience.
  2. Relevance to the Question:
    • Directly addresses the decline of liberalism, citing specific causes such as right-wing movements and postmodern critiques.
  3. Inclusion of Examples and Thinkers:
    • Use of real-world examples (rise of right-wing politics in Europe and the USA) makes the argument concrete.
    • References to Locke, Nietzsche, and Derrida add intellectual depth and credibility.
  4. Balanced Perspective:
    • Highlights both the challenges faced by liberalism and its historical resilience, providing a nuanced view.

Weaknesses:

  1. Limited Explanation of Key Terms:
    • Concepts like “postmodernism” and “universal values” are mentioned but not fully explained, which may confuse readers unfamiliar with these ideas.
  2. Insufficient Examples:
    • The answer could benefit from more diverse examples, such as liberalism’s decline in the Global South or its struggles in addressing economic inequality.
  3. Word Limit Efficiency:
    • While concise, the answer could further trim repetitive phrases to provide more depth within the 150-word constraint.
  4. Future Outlook:
    • The discussion on liberalism’s potential to adapt is optimistic but lacks specific suggestions on how it might incorporate contemporary changes.

Overall Assessment:

The answer effectively addresses the decline of liberalism and provides a balanced perspective. To improve, it should offer more detailed explanations, include diverse examples, and suggest specific ways for liberalism to adapt to modern challenges. It scores well on structure and relevance but could enhance its analytical depth and comprehensive coverage.


Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top